Xavi Simons scout report: Why Liverpool and Newcastle are fighting for him

Xavi Simons scout report: The rise of a dynamic playmaker

In the 2025-26 season, Xavi Simons has emerged as one of Europe’s most exciting attacking midfielders. After a prolific spell at PSV Eindhoven — where he scored 18 goals and provided 12 assists — he completed a high-profile move to AS Roma in January 2026. Since arriving in Italy, his performances have sparked transfer interest from Liverpool and Newcastle United, both seeking a creative spark in midfield.

Operating primarily as a left-sided attacking midfielder or inverted winger, Simons thrives in tight spaces. His 87% pass accuracy in the final third and 3.4 shots per 90 minutes highlight his dual threat as a creator and scorer. Coached by Daniele De Rossi, he has refined his movement between the lines, making him a constant outlet in transition. Despite his attacking flair, his defensive work rate remains a concern, averaging just 1.2 tackles per game.

Experts believe Simons combines technical brilliance with intelligent movement, making him ideal for high-intensity, possession-based systems.

Strengths: What makes Xavi Simons special

Simons’ greatest asset is his close control and ability to beat defenders in one-on-one situations. With a dribble success rate of 68%, he ranks among Serie A’s elite dribblers. His low center of gravity allows him to shift direction quickly, making him dangerous in half-spaces. He’s also adept at cutting inside onto his stronger right foot, where his enrobed shot has already troubled top keepers like Mike Maignan and Vicario.

Beyond individual skill, Simons reads the game well. He times his runs into the box effectively and links play with quick one-twos, particularly with Roma’s overlapping full-backs. His chemistry with Stephan El Shaarawy and Edoardo Bove has been crucial in Roma’s push for European qualification.

Weaknesses: Where he still needs to improve

While his offensive output is impressive, Simons’ defensive contribution lags behind modern expectations. He often drifts out of position when pressing, leaving gaps in midfield. His interceptions per 90 (0.8) are below average for a central playmaker in top leagues. Additionally, he can be inconsistent over full seasons — his form dipped briefly in November 2025 at PSV due to fitness issues.

Physicality is another area for growth. At 1.78m and 68kg, he can be overpowered by stronger defenders, especially in Premier League encounters. Adapting to the faster pace and physical demands of English football will be his biggest challenge if he moves to Liverpool or Newcastle.

Transfer: Best fit — Liverpool or Newcastle?

Liverpool, under Arne Slot, play a fluid 4-3-3 with heavy reliance on full-backs as playmakers. Simons could thrive as a right-sided forward, rotating with Mohamed Salah and Darwin Núñez. His creativity would ease the burden on Trent Alexander-Arnold and add unpredictability to the attack.

Newcastle United, rebuilding after Alexander Isak’s departure, need a dynamic creator. While their style is more direct, Simons’ pace and shooting ability could suit their counter-attacking approach. However, he might struggle with the team’s lower possession share compared to Liverpool’s ball-dominant system.

• Xavi Simons has 18 goals and 12 assists in the 2025-26 season across Eredivisie and Serie A.
• His 87% pass accuracy in the final third shows elite-level vision and composure.
• Liverpool is seen as the more tactically suitable destination for his skill set.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How old is Xavi Simons?

A: Xavi Simons was born on April 21, 2003. As of April 2026, he is 22 years old. He is widely regarded as one of the brightest young talents in European football.

Q: What is Xavi Simons's market value?

A: According to Transfermarkt, Xavi Simons has a market value of approximately €60 million in April 2026. This figure could rise significantly if he maintains his current form and secures a move to the Premier League.

Q: Which club will sign Xavi Simons?

A: While Simons is under contract with AS Roma until 2030, reports suggest a release clause of €75 million could be triggered this summer. Liverpool are favourites, but Newcastle United are preparing a competitive bid to lure him to the Premier League.